By the time the last of the leaf peepers head back over the bridge, most of us on the Cape are thinking about how to thank the people who got us through another season. For a lot of owners, that means a gift card in a card, a bonus in the last check of the year, or a ham for everyone who stuck around after Columbus Day.
All three are lovely gestures, and the IRS treats them very differently. One of them can go out without payroll ever hearing about it, and the other two need to show up on your staff’s W-2s, however small the amount. It’s much easier to know “Are gift cards taxable to employees?” in November, before the envelopes go out, than in January when someone is trying to reconcile the business credit card.
Why a Gift Card to an Employee Shows Up on Their W-2
A gift card you give an employee is taxable wages no matter how small it is, so it belongs on their W-2 along with the rest of their pay.
The IRS is unusually direct about this. In IRS Publication 15-B, it says cash and cash equivalents, “for example, gift certificates, gift cards, and the use of a charge card or credit card,” are never excludable as a de minimis benefit, “no matter how little.” A small card to the coffee shop in Hyannis gets the same treatment as a big one to the hardware store.
The reasoning is that a gift card spends like cash, and cash you hand an employee is pay, so the card goes through payroll with the usual withholding and shows up in their year-end wages. The same publication says a taxable fringe benefit is “generally subject to employment taxes and must be reported on Form W-2.”
Let’s look at an example, one we see in the office almost every January. A restaurant in Orleans with ten year-round staff hands each of them a $100 gift card in December, paid for on the business credit card. Payroll never hears about it, nobody’s W-2 includes it, and the bookkeeper files the charge under “gifts.” Every one of those cards was wages, and sorting it out in January is a lot more work than adding a line to the December payroll would have been.
That catches a lot of good people off guard, because the card feels like a present and not like a paycheck, and unfortunately the tax code only cares what it is.
The Holiday Ham Stays Off the W-2, and the Gift Card Doesn’t
A small, non-cash holiday gift is usually a de minimis fringe benefit, which means you can give it without running it through payroll at all. The IRS lists “holiday or birthday gifts, other than cash, with a low fair market value” as one of its own examples, along with “occasional parties or picnics for employees and their guests.”
The idea behind de minimis is that if something has so little value that tracking it would be unreasonable, the IRS doesn’t make you track it. It also looks at how often you give it, so a ham at the holidays is a different thing from a ham every Friday.
That’s why the holiday ham, the turkey, the box of chocolates from the shop down the road, or a fleece with your logo on it can generally go out without payroll getting involved. The IRS doesn’t put a dollar figure on “low value,” so we’d keep these modest and occasional rather than go looking for the line.
Holiday Bonuses Run Through Payroll Like Any Other Wages
A holiday bonus is wages, and it goes through payroll with withholding just like a regular paycheck. IRS Publication 15 lists bonuses right alongside salaries and commissions as wages subject to federal employment taxes, and it calls them supplemental wages for withholding purposes.
That supplemental label matters because it gives you two ways to figure federal income tax withholding. For an employee whose regular pay you already withhold on, if you pay the bonus separately, or in the same check but listed as its own line, you can withhold a flat 22%, and Publication 15 is clear there’s “no other percentage allowed“. The other choice is to add the bonus to regular pay and withhold on the total as if it were one normal paycheck, which is also what happens if you fold the bonus in without separating it.
Pub 15 also notes the 22% rate stays put because recent federal tax legislation made the current individual rates permanent, with a 37% rate that only kicks in once one employee’s supplemental wages pass $1 million in a year, which we don’t see a lot of in holiday bonuses on the Cape.
Either way, Social Security and Medicare come out of the bonus too, and you pay your employer share on it, which is the part owners tend to forget when they promise someone “an extra $500” in October.
How Do You Gross Up a Bonus So Your Staff Get the Round Number?
Grossing up means working backward from the amount you want the employee to actually take home, so the bonus is paid in a larger amount that covers the withholding. If you promise $500 and pay a $500 bonus, the employee sees noticeably less than $500 once federal withholding, Social Security, Medicare and Massachusetts withholding have all come out.
There’s nothing wrong with paying the bonus straight, as long as everyone knows what to expect. Where it goes sideways is when you tell someone they’re getting $500, and they open a check for something smaller, which isn’t the warm feeling you were going for.
If you do want the round number to land, the payroll system can figure the gross amount for you, but it needs to know you want a gross-up before the run, not after. The grossed-up amount is the bonus, so that full amount is what goes on the W-2 and what you pay your employer taxes on. It’s worth budgeting for before you make the promise.
Massachusetts Treats Gift Cards and Bonuses as Wages Too
Massachusetts follows the federal definition of wages for withholding, so a gift card or bonus that’s taxable wages for the IRS is wages for the state as well. The state’s withholding law defines wages as “wages as defined in section thirty-four hundred and one (a) of the Internal Revenue Code“, which is the same federal section Pub 15 works from.
State law requires every employer to “deduct and withhold a tax upon such wages” using the Department of Revenue’s tables, and your payroll software applies those for you as long as the payment goes through payroll in the first place.
So a gift card handed out off the books leaves the state wages and state withholding short as well as the federal W-2.
We’ve written about the Massachusetts payroll taxes Cape Cod business owners keep getting wrong, and quietly skipping payroll on holiday extras is right up there.
What Can Your Business Deduct for Employee Gifts and the Holiday Party?
What you give your own staff generally counts as compensation, and compensation is deductible as wages, so the $25 business gift limit isn’t the rule that applies to them. IRS Publication 463 caps business gifts at $25 per person per year, but that cap covers gifts the recipient can exclude from income, and the tax code says gifts from an employer to an employee aren’t excludable that way.
In practice, the gift card you ran through payroll is deducted with the rest of your wages. Small non-cash gifts have their own rules, and anything edible is worth a quick conversation with us this year, since the rules for deducting food provided to employees changed after 2025. The $25 cap is really about the fruit basket you send your best customer, not the people on your own payroll.
The holiday party gets its own treatment. Publication 15-B says food and drink for employee recreation, “such as holiday parties or annual picnics,” remain 100% deductible. The catch is that the party has to be mainly for employees other than owners with a 10% or greater stake, officers, or other highly compensated employees, so a “party” that’s really the owners and their spouses at a nice dinner in Chatham won’t qualify. If you’re planning one this year, our tips for hosting an employee holiday party that’s festive, frugal and free of stress still hold up.
Getting Everything Into the Last Payroll of the Year
The simplest way to handle all of this is to decide on your gifts and bonuses before your final payroll run of the year and put every taxable piece through that run. Gift cards, cash bonuses, and any gross-ups all get entered as wages, and the ham and the party stay out.
A short list helps: who’s getting what, whether each item is cash, a gift card or non-cash, and whether bonuses go in a separate check, sent to whoever runs your payroll a few days before the last pay date. That way the withholding method is the one you chose and not whatever the software defaults to.
If you’d rather not be the one keeping track, this is exactly the kind of thing Atlantic Payroll, our outsourced payroll service for Cape Cod businesses, handles every December, from setting up the bonus run to making sure the gift cards land on the W-2s where they belong.
And if the bigger problem is that the books behind the payroll are a mess, our BOSS outsourced accounting service keeps them in order all year.
This is general information, and the right answer for your business depends on how you pay your staff and what you’re planning to give. If you want a second set of eyes on your year-end plans, reach out to Steven M. Ellard, CPA, and we’ll walk through it with you before the last payroll runs.
If you liked this one, you might also like the payroll mistakes we see most often on Cape Cod and how to catch them before they get expensive.
Until next time!





